giovedì 20 gennaio 2011

Menchov not invited at Tour de France:

As you probably know, today ASO has published the list of teams invited to this year edition of Tour de France. To my horror, the name of Geox team didn't appear on said list. The teams that were invited to the prestigious French race in fact were Cofidis, FDJ, Team Europcar and, dulcis in fundo, the super famous Saur-Sojasun team. After all, why should ASO have invited Menchov and Sastre's team when they knew they could have Casper and Coppel's equipe? It would have been a non-sense choice! Moreover, Saur-Sojasun team kits perfectly match the colour of Movistar's ones and this fact may cause some confusion between supporters. What a joy! And, perhaps, after being invited to the Tour this team will assume such a 'grandeuristic' attitude that they'll start to send mails to the journalists and tell them to write the team's name in capitals. That would be great for French cycling, wouldn't it? And then, Saur-Sojasun is a French team, so its riders will surely enter a breakaway on the Bastille Day, won't dope during the race and they won't force French journalists to speak English. And then, in this team there are so many unknown riders! I mean, Geox has Sastre and Menchov, ok, but none of them is a great beauty, right? And then, those guys have been racing for about 10 years now, we supporters are fed up with them! So, let's give space to French teams, they deserve it so much! And then, let's not forget that Geox kit may look like Footon-Servetto's old one and ASO guys don't want naked-looking guys riding on the French roads in July, right? It would damage tourism!!
I'm trying to be funny while writing this post but, believe me, I am scandalised, I mean, 's-c-a-n-d-a-l-i-s-e-d-', by ASO's decision. Ok, Carlos Sastre was pretty disappointing in the last 2 seasons, but you can't decide not to invite Menchov at the Tour! How can a person without mental problems consciounsly decide not to invite him there? Denis is the most complete Grand Tour rider of the world (Andy Schleck is better than him on the climbs, but the Russian is better in time trials) and was 3rd in the last Tour; moreover, in the last years he won two Vueltas and a Giro. Why not inviting him then? What kind of illegal substance damaged the brain of ASO's guys so much to make them take this decision? Did they sniff clenbuterol?
'Contador has damaged cycling', McQuaid has recently said in an interview. Well, in my opinion ASO organisers have just joined the Spaniard in his attempt of trying to disgust cycling supporters once again.
As a supporter, every time I watch a Grand Tour I hope that, in the end, its winner will be a rider that has deserved that victory. A rider that isn't doped, a rider that has made me feel strong emotions, a rider that has beated all the other strongest riders of the world. This happens to be particularly true for the Tour de France, the most important cycling Grand Tour of the world. All the best riders of the world should be able to take part in it, no matter the Pro Tour systems or b******** like that. Then it's true that it's almost impossible to have all the best riders of the world in the same race, because unfortunately there is always someone who is injured or has had health problems or so on. But still, I think that the best riders of the world shouldn't be excluded by the most important race of the world because of the organisers' stupidity. Because, when a team as Geox is excluded from a race like the Tour, then it means that we're not talking cycling anymore. It means that we're talking politics, patriotism, revenge or things like that. But we're not talking sport. And sport, when I watch cycling races, is the only thing I actually care about.
Talking about cycling races, the Tour is considered the best Grand Tour of the world. Therefore, from the theoric point of view, the rider who wins it should be the best Grand Tour rider of the world. Now, me wonders: how can we know if 2011 TdF winner would have beaten Menchov if he had had the chance to race? Personally, if right now I were a Tour de France's possible contender, I wouldn't be happy to know about Denis' exclusion from the race. In my opinion, in fact, a Tour without all the best riders of the world is a Tour without value.
Talking about Menchov, I really don't know how he must be feeling right now and I wouldn't like to be in his shoes tonight. I mean, Denis was born in 1978 (on the 25th of January), isn't a 'young gun' anymore and, perhaps, he won't have many other years at this level in front of him. If I were him, I would be terribly angry at ASO right now. Perhaps they didn't realise it, but with their decision the ASO guys might have just destroyed Menchov's sportive dream. It's easy for us to say 'He can always try to win the race next year', but there are many things that can change in 365 days time- everything can change in 365 days time.
Now of course Menchov and Sastre hope that their team will be invited to Giro and the Corsa Rosa will become their main goal of the season. Hopefully mr. Zomegnan cares about cycling more than his colleagues at ASO and so he will invite Geox to his race.
It will surely take me some time to get used to the idea that Menchov won't race the Tour, but perhaps the most disgusting thing about this story is that supporters can't do nothing about it. Riders are said to count nothing in the cycling world, but supporters count even less than them. 'It's another defeat for cycling, it's another delusion for the tifosi, it's another blow for cycling's credibility!', that's what Very Important People say every time a rider is caught positive at the anti-doping. Too bad that, imo, also not inviting the best riders to the most important race of the world is a loss of credibility for cycling, another defeat for the sport and, most important, another delusion for the tifosi. Personally, I've rarely felt so disappointed because of cycling. People always believe there's justice in this world, too bad that it's not true... Btw, I realise that I'm slipping into cliché, moralism and all those kind of things, so it's better if I stop this post here. The lack of solutions for this situation leaves me disappointed and disgusted, powerless and worried.
Unfortunately there is nothing we can do about it, apart from thinking that, of course, there are more important things in the world (and I'm perfectly aware of this, don't worry). For example, HTC Columbia rider Carla Swart, 23 year-old, died the other day while training. My deepest condolences go to her familiars and friends.

PS1: I wrote this post as soon as I got the news of ASO's decision, when I was even angrier than now at the Tour organisers, therefore anger might have caused me to make more mistakes than usual int. If so, I apology.

PS2: in the first part of this post I wrote about Saur-Sojasun. I want to make it clear that I don't have nothing against that team and that I perfectly know that it's not their fault if Menchov's team was excluded from the Tour.

19 commenti:

  1. This is really unbelievable news! That means possibly the first place rider and definitely the third place rider from last year's TdF won't be in this year's tour. L-O-L That doesn't make sense, but I don't understand enough about the wild card places to make sense of it.

    Of course, I would love to see Andy win, but in a good competition! With top riders!

    Hi Fede! Leela gave a shout out to your blog, and here I am! I've been enjoying reading and catching up. Great to see so many Schlecklanders, new faces, and even the Coug is here!!

    -Gnasher

    RispondiElimina
  2. Hi Natasha! Nice to see you here with Coug and the other Schlecklanders! :) Talking about CG, I'm happy to tell you that she has published a new, funny post on http://eisenandy.blogspot.com/ which, I suppose, it's her new blog :)

    This Menchov-news is unbelievable indeed. Poor guy, he's always so nice with everyone! He didn't deserve this. Moreover, poor Denis has birthday in 5 days time and he probably won't be in the best mood for his party :(

    However, if I was Prudhomme, I would be careful with Menchov: according to English Wikipedia, one of his nicknames is 'The Silent Assassin'... :P

    RispondiElimina
  3. Tour de France is the French national tour and like every other national tour ASO has a certain responsibility towards the national teams - BUT I don't understand how they cannot invite the third place back. Tour de France is also the best Grand Tour as you say and so they ought to invite the best riders. Obviously ASO wants to support French cycling (and they should) and since there's only one French ProTeam support is needed but they could have let out Saur-Sojasun.

    I'm actually more worried about what will now happen with Geox. They had some issues and maybe they were blown a bit out of proportions by the press but the sponsors can't be happy right now...

    RispondiElimina
  4. I completely agree with you, Susanne.
    I understand that Prudhomme wants to support French cycling, but I thought that inviting 3 French teams out of 4 would have been enough. Apparently, I was wrong.

    Geox situation is terribly worrying. Geox' chief had become very angry at Gianetti (the ds) when he failed to get a Pro Tour license for the team. Now Geox has to rely on the invitations of GT organisers and I've always thought that they would have had more problems with the Giro's invitation than with the Tour de France one. I mean, I had imagined that Prudhomme was going to invite Europcar, FDJ and Cofidis at the Tour, but I thought that then he would have invited Denis' team. But he didn't, and now Geox is waiting to know whether it can take part in the Giro or not.
    The problem is that the organisers of Tirreno-Adriatico have just communicated that they're not going to invite Geox at their race and this is a very bad sign, since RCS organises also the Giro, the Tour of Lombardy and, if I remember correctly, also the Milan-Sanremo. Moreover, it is already known that Zomegnan is going to invite Androni-Giocattoli and Farnese Vini to the Giro. That leaves room for other two teams, but we must remember that between Professional Italian teams there are Acqua&Sapone (which has Garzelli) and Colnago, which has interesting young riders like Modolo and Belletti and a good climber like Pozzovivo. So, I'm afraid that it's not 100% sure for Geox to be invited at the Giro.

    I'm really, really worried for the future of Geox' riders right now. Menchov and Sastre can always get a new team, but the less known riders will surely have more problems. And it's all ASO's fault!!

    RispondiElimina
  5. I thought they were pretty much a given at the Tour de France as well but apparently not. Let's hope Geox will be invited to the Giro - if not, I think it'll pretty much be the end of it. But since they haven't been invited to Tirreno-Adriatico it doesn't look good.

    RispondiElimina
  6. I can't believe this year I'll be watching the Tour WITHOUT Denis Menchov there. I just can't imagine it. This is unforgivable. A

    RispondiElimina
  7. Some guy from Skil-Shimano (also not invited) said it was no suprise that Skil was not invited. He already knew that those patriotic idiots were going to pick the French team.
    But with Menchov on the team, I really thought Geox had a change to be picked.. Boohooo

    (Btw, does anyone else think that Saur-Sojasun sounds like sour sundried soy?)

    RispondiElimina
  8. Hiya Fede! Have you blown off all your steam? :-)
    It doesn't surprise me that ASO invited only French teams, so I'm not surprised that politics don't make exception for exceptional riders. It is a pity really and a disappointment, supporters become jaded a bit more every time.
    Anyway, as Italian I'm genetically encoded to be nuts over conspiration theories, undercover deals and all that jazz, so I ask you: do you think Denis could land in Saxo Bank as plan B of the plan B? Me would like it, the Silent Assassin still retains his license to kill.

    @Mar: I like your vegan option, the first time I read the name it was "Sauron soyasauce". I need glasses.

    Francesca

    RispondiElimina
  9. As far as organization is concerned, I have no idea how things work in cycling (or any other sport, for that matter). But I don't need such knowledge to see how ridiculous it is to not invite a top rider to a top event.

    And while I'm at it, the whole concept of "inviting" makes no sense to start with. In my understanding, all ProTour teams have to race all ProTour events (Grand Tours included), while some group of people gets to decide which other teams, um... deserve to race and which don't? Wouldn't it be more sensible if there were some kind of qualifications? I mean, almost every other sport has qualifications you have to pass in order to compete at top level. I can see why that would be difficult in this particular case, but there's gotta be some more fair way of deciding who races and who doesn't.
    Of course, I might as well have misunderstood the whole thing and just be embarrassing myself.

    @ Mar and Francesca
    It does indeed sound like sour soyasauce xD

    On a side note, where did my comment (basically this one, without the soy sauce part) disappear. I'm quite sure I saw it posted...

    RispondiElimina
  10. Oh I love sarcastic fangirl ;)

    I can't believe they wouldn't invite the team with the rider who placed 3rd in last years tour!!

    Also, I really hate when politics comes into sport!!

    And that's my 2 cents worth (not much today sorry), I've been MIA this week since I'm at the tennis!

    RispondiElimina
  11. Seriously, why do my posts keep disappearing?

    Last night was quite late, so I might have not even posted it (though I'm pretty sure I had), but I am 100% positive that I saw the today's one posted and it's not here.

    Cristin

    RispondiElimina
  12. @Cristin: I see your posts appearing and disappearing like a karst river.

    Francesca

    RispondiElimina
  13. Forget about it, they've both magically appeared xD

    I'm sorry

    RispondiElimina
  14. @ Cristin: I've solved your problem! Unfortunately my blog seems to have big problems with its spam folder right now. It never recognises spams, but it hides comments from normal readers. Unfortunately this thing doesn't depend on my will and I can't do nothing about it.
    If someone posts something and after some time they notice that their comment has disappearead, let me know about it and I'll take a look at the spam folder.
    Unfortunately it seems that there's no way to make that folder disappear and I'm very sorry for the problems that it's causing :(

    I think you're completely right about the invitation system. Race organisers should invite the best teams to their races, without caring about nationality, budget or other stupid factors!
    I agree with you also about the fact that the invitation system is a b*******. If I was Giro organisers, and knew that a team is not going to bring its best riders to my race, I wouldn't invite that team and I would call a strong professional team at its place. Instead, they can't do this because of the ProTour.
    Imo, the whole ProTour system sucks, also because of the calendar. I mean, every year they put the Giro of California in May, although they know that in May there is the Giro and that many riders (Cavendish, for example) are forced to race in USA and not in Italy by their sponsors. I think that this is a horrible behaviour, because imo Tour of California will never have Giro's tradition, no matter how hard they try to bring the race at the best level (national pride is speaking!). Stupid ProTour system!

    @ Susanne: I have a bad feeling about Geox's invitation to the Giro. Not only RCS didn't invite it to Tirreno-Adriatico, but today's Gazzetta spent just one line to talk about Menchov's exclusion from The Tour. Moreover, Gazzetta didn't complain about ASO's decision and, considering that Giro d'Italia is Gazzetta's race, I'm afraid that this may be a very bad sign for Menchov and his teammates :(

    @ A: I agree with you. What ASO did is unforgivable. I'm afraid I'll spend a lot of time in July thinking about Denis. And if Contador was at the start of the race, I'd get even more angrier at Prudhomme!

    @ Mar: yes, it does indeed! :)
    Skill Shimano is another team who has some good riders, but never gets invited to important races. And to say that Kenny Van Hummel had become a hero for many tifosi in 2009!

    @ Francesca: unfortunately I haven't blown off my steam yet. I was eager to read Gazzetta's cycling page today, instead they dedicated just one line to this scandal and published a big interview with Riccò. Could things have been worse?
    I still haven't realised that Menchov is really going to lose this year Tour, I hope it was just a bad dream.

    As Italian, I go nuts on conspiracy theories too and I'm glad you gave me the chance to talk about them ;) I think that signing Menchov would be a great deal for Bjarne, especially if Contador gets a 2 year-ban. Riis needs a strong, experienced Grand Tour rider that can get in the Tour Top 10 and, on the other hand, I'm sure that Menchov would kill (Prudhomme could be a good victim...) to ride this year Tour. So, if they can, I think they may try to get in touch with each other.
    I'd be so happy if Menchov really raced the Tour!

    @ Leela: the relationship between sport and politics will actually be the theme of my 'Maturità' thesis and the question I'll ask myself in it is: 'Is it good when sport and politics get mixed up?' After yesterday, my answer to that question is a loud 'NOOOOO!' (before of yesterday, it was a 'NOOOO!', with just 4 'o's).

    Have fun at the tennis tournament!!!

    RispondiElimina
  15. The Barnaby Riis-Menchov combination doesn't seem unlikely. I mean, SaxoBlank is definitely looking into other options. They really need a plan B and I just read that they're considering Luke Roberts so obviously they are considering a plan B - and Menchov would be a very good plan B if he should decide to leave Geox.

    But good news for Geox and Menchov: they're invited to Milano-Sanremo so maybe the Giro isn't out of the question just yet.

    RispondiElimina
  16. Everything you wrote is SO TRUE! My sister also wrote a new "Dear..." on our blog about it with pretty much the same arguments you mentioned. We also think that it's so nationalistic of the French to do that and just like you said, doping affects cycling, but these organisations banning some of the competition, in this case Menchov and Sastre, is just as unbelievable and unfair :( Poor Denis and Carlos.. damn, I think I'll realise this when the Tour starts.. It doesn't seem real to me yet right now.. :(

    If some of you need some cheering up after this sad news (like I did).. you can click on my name and on the right you'll see a very cute picture of Richie Porte and his new friend ;) A guaranteed smile.

    RispondiElimina
  17. @ Susanne: that is a good news for Geox indeed. I so hope they'll be invited at the Giro!

    Saxo Bank could be a perfect plan B for Denis. Btw I've just read an interview with Menchov and in it he said he doesn't regret his team choice and that he likes Geox very much. Let's hope he'll be able to ride the Giro for Geox then!

    @ Marleen: I've read the post on your blog and I agree with everything you wrote. You can be patriotic if you organise your town's little race, not if you organise a Tour de France. Frenchmen are said to be extremely patriotic, but I didn't think that ASO could take such an unfair decision just because of nationalistic reasons.
    Poor Denis, he'd deserve to take part in the Tour much more than many other guys in the peloton and now he won't be able to take part in it just because of some stupid race organisers. I can't believe it yet :(

    The picture made me smile and cheered me up :) Kangaroos are so sweet! The other evening I saw the beginning of TDU's coverageon Italian tv (unfortunately I couldn't see it all because it was too late for me) and there was a little kangaroo that was smelling the face of a rider in a terribly cute way! Kangaroos are such sweet animals, they look so soft and tender!! :)

    RispondiElimina
  18. Now Denis is going to focus on the Giro and the Vuelta.. I hope he wins them both!! ;) Okay, ofcourse that's not realistic, but a girl can dream right? :P Everything to piss off those patriotic French dudes.. Yes, I'm still sad about it.

    Yes, I love kangaroos too.. so sweet! Here's another thing to cheer us up.. (maybe you already saw it).. It's a video of Michael Matthews, the Aussie talent from Rabobank. He sure knows how to move.. ;) - 1:10 -
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDAc-AvaB5w

    RispondiElimina
  19. Menchov is a very talented guys, I think he has the skills to end up in th Top 3 both at the Giro and at la Vuelta. Imo for him it'd be enough to win the Giro. The Tour starts a month after it and, if Menchov won the Giro, Prudhomme would surely have to face thousands of journalists and supporters asking him why he didn't invite Menchov to his race. It's not a good revenge, but it's better than nothing.

    Hey, that video is great! Matthews surely knows how to move (and how to win races, of course)!
    Perhaps I should try dancing like that before of my school tests, it may bring me good luck ;)

    RispondiElimina